Lure variability

If you use artificial lures to catch any predator this is the forum for you
Post Reply
Oldskoolfool
Perch
Perch
Posts: 597
Joined: Wed Oct 30 2019 19:53

Lure variability

Post by Oldskoolfool »

Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.

Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
User avatar
Steve Dennington
Zander
Zander
Posts: 6036
Joined: Mon Aug 29 2011 05:00
Location: Suffolk

Re: Lure variability

Post by Steve Dennington »

Oh no, Burts again! :laughs:

Weighted Burts are very inconsistent in the ballast department. The ballast itself consists of lead balls around 10mm in diameter, but the number inserted has varied in mine from just one up to three! The ones with three are the biggest PITA because they sink nose first, which is fine if you want them to but most people don't. Fortunately, the moulded body is consistent, so removing or adding ballast in the various chambers gives you a variety of good actions.

The early Fox lures were mostly wood weren't they? :scratch:
Jack H
Jack Pike
Jack Pike
Posts: 300
Joined: Tue Oct 31 2023 20:31

Re: Lure variability

Post by Jack H »

I’ve just re weighted a burt to fish slightly deeper than it did out of the box. Agree on the older fox lures. I’ve got a rooter which has a great action, whereas I’ve got a gremlin that doesn’t do a lot. All the ones I’ve got appear to be wooden. Probably fairly poor quality.

Jack
Jack H
Jack Pike
Jack Pike
Posts: 300
Joined: Tue Oct 31 2023 20:31

Re: Lure variability

Post by Jack H »

Jack H wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 11:32 -
I’ve just re weighted a burt to fish slightly deeper than it did out of the box, by adding lead to the nose. Worked ok, but unsure how you’d get a sinking one to float :laughs: . Agree on the older fox lures. I’ve got a rooter which has a great action, whereas I’ve got a gremlin that doesn’t do a lot. All the ones I’ve got appear to be wooden. Probably fairly poor quality.

Jack
User avatar
Mike J
Ferox Trout
Ferox Trout
Posts: 11094
Joined: Wed Nov 09 2016 09:26
Location: Wessex

Re: Lure variability

Post by Mike J »

Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.

Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
'No Man Ever Fishes The Same River Twice, .... For It Is Not The Same River, .... And He Is Not The Same Man' Heraclitus of Ephesus
User avatar
DaveGreenwood
Zander
Zander
Posts: 5660
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: On Top

Re: Lure variability

Post by DaveGreenwood »

Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.

Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
User avatar
old_school
Roach
Roach
Posts: 162
Joined: Sat Nov 05 2016 18:26
Location: Derbyshire

Re: Lure variability

Post by old_school »

DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
If you always fish where others fish, you'll always catch what others catch.
User avatar
DaveGreenwood
Zander
Zander
Posts: 5660
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: On Top

Re: Lure variability

Post by DaveGreenwood »

old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
No mate there's no need hardwood dive and rise baits are perfect for it, I'm in the if it works leave it camp.
User avatar
old_school
Roach
Roach
Posts: 162
Joined: Sat Nov 05 2016 18:26
Location: Derbyshire

Re: Lure variability

Post by old_school »

Clipped a 25gm weight on the nose of a burt that was the right colour but wrong weight for the peg the other day, fished like a house brick but still had one! My mate been trying for years and has yet to catch one on a burt, they certainly are a marmite lure
If you always fish where others fish, you'll always catch what others catch.
User avatar
Steve Dennington
Zander
Zander
Posts: 6036
Joined: Mon Aug 29 2011 05:00
Location: Suffolk

Re: Lure variability

Post by Steve Dennington »

old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -

It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Variable ballast dive/rise baits with screw-in weights of various sizes are becoming increasing popular in the States. It's a system that I'm going to add to some of the ones I make this year. Not all of them though, because fixed ballast makes a better/neater looking bait.
User avatar
davelumb
Forum Sponsor
Forum Sponsor
Posts: 42608
Joined: Sat Aug 27 2011 05:00
Location: On some faraway beach
Contact:

Re: Lure variability

Post by davelumb »

Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.

Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
It doesn't apply to everything. My Mexican made Fender guitars are not much different to my USA made one. They're certainly not half as good despite being less than half the price when I bought them.

Pete Maina used to cut Burts up and glue in tails in his garage when I started dealing with him!
User avatar
Mike J
Ferox Trout
Ferox Trout
Posts: 11094
Joined: Wed Nov 09 2016 09:26
Location: Wessex

Re: Lure variability

Post by Mike J »

old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Ive fished with a few lures and gave my first DG lure a swim the other day. Not my first custom lure by any means but my first from Dave. You all know how it goes, buy one and give it a good trial, if it looks decent and catches buy more, if something is not quite right store it.
Anyways, hand in heart I can say its the very best slow sinker Ive ever fished, its sink rate is apx 1"/second, yes, seriously slow and-and it sinks level with just a tiny wobble.
Id like to say I caught with it but as of yet I don't even know if there is a pike in the place.

.
'No Man Ever Fishes The Same River Twice, .... For It Is Not The Same River, .... And He Is Not The Same Man' Heraclitus of Ephesus
User avatar
old_school
Roach
Roach
Posts: 162
Joined: Sat Nov 05 2016 18:26
Location: Derbyshire

Re: Lure variability

Post by old_school »

Mike J wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:00 -
old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Ive fished with a few lures and gave my first DG lure a swim the other day. Not my first custom lure by any means but my first from Dave. You all know how it goes, buy one and give it a good trial, if it looks decent and catches buy more, if something is not quite right store it.
Anyways, hand in heart I can say its the very best slow sinker Ive ever fished, its sink rate is apx 1"/second, yes, seriously slow and-and it sinks level with just a tiny wobble.
Id like to say I caught with it but as of yet I don't even know if there is a pike in the place.

.
Hey Mike, I’ve got a few of Dave’s and the big dippers are superb, can get them deeper than burts and they are more stable, harder wearing too, give one a go if you haven’t all ready, I’ve had several double on the BDs and always one in my box 😎
If you always fish where others fish, you'll always catch what others catch.
User avatar
DaveGreenwood
Zander
Zander
Posts: 5660
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: On Top

Re: Lure variability

Post by DaveGreenwood »

Mike J wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:00 -
old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Ive fished with a few lures and gave my first DG lure a swim the other day. Not my first custom lure by any means but my first from Dave. You all know how it goes, buy one and give it a good trial, if it looks decent and catches buy more, if something is not quite right store it.
Anyways, hand in heart I can say its the very best slow sinker Ive ever fished, its sink rate is apx 1"/second, yes, seriously slow and-and it sinks level with just a tiny wobble.
Id like to say I caught with it but as of yet I don't even know if there is a pike in the place.

.
Thanks Mike I’m sure you’ll do well on it once you find some Pike :thumbs:
User avatar
DaveGreenwood
Zander
Zander
Posts: 5660
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: On Top

Re: Lure variability

Post by DaveGreenwood »

old_school wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:47 -
Mike J wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:00 -
old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Ive fished with a few lures and gave my first DG lure a swim the other day. Not my first custom lure by any means but my first from Dave. You all know how it goes, buy one and give it a good trial, if it looks decent and catches buy more, if something is not quite right store it.
Anyways, hand in heart I can say its the very best slow sinker Ive ever fished, its sink rate is apx 1"/second, yes, seriously slow and-and it sinks level with just a tiny wobble.
Id like to say I caught with it but as of yet I don't even know if there is a pike in the place.

.
Hey Mike, I’ve got a few of Dave’s and the big dippers are superb, can get them deeper than burts and they are more stable, harder wearing too, give one a go if you haven’t all ready, I’ve had several double on the BDs and always one in my box 😎
Thanks Paul :handshake: :clap:
andrew_nagel
Zander
Zander
Posts: 5604
Joined: Mon Aug 29 2011 05:00

Re: Lure variability

Post by andrew_nagel »

I've managed to smuggle a few of Dave's creations across the north sea. The Danish, Swedish, Norwegian and German pike approve.
User avatar
DaveGreenwood
Zander
Zander
Posts: 5660
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: On Top

Re: Lure variability

Post by DaveGreenwood »

andrew_nagel wrote: Thu Jan 18 2024 02:34 -
I've managed to smuggle a few of Dave's creations across the north sea. The Danish, Swedish, Norwegian and German pike approve.
Crafty, :cool: :thumbs:

Another 30 caught on one of mine 2 weeks ago :grin:
User avatar
Mike J
Ferox Trout
Ferox Trout
Posts: 11094
Joined: Wed Nov 09 2016 09:26
Location: Wessex

Re: Lure variability

Post by Mike J »

old_school wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:47 -
Mike J wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:00 -
old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Ive fished with a few lures and gave my first DG lure a swim the other day. Not my first custom lure by any means but my first from Dave. You all know how it goes, buy one and give it a good trial, if it looks decent and catches buy more, if something is not quite right store it.
Anyways, hand in heart I can say its the very best slow sinker Ive ever fished, its sink rate is apx 1"/second, yes, seriously slow and-and it sinks level with just a tiny wobble.
Id like to say I caught with it but as of yet I don't even know if there is a pike in the place.

.
Hey Mike, I’ve got a few of Dave’s and the big dippers are superb, can get them deeper than burts and they are more stable, harder wearing too, give one a go if you haven’t all ready, I’ve had several double on the BDs and always one in my box 😎

I haven't a clue what mine is called, just saw a pic and thought thats what I want, chatted to Dave and he sent me a pic when he'd finished it. Not my first from a PP lure maker (the other was hopeless) so it was a bit of a risk but Dave's mileage gave me the confidence. When the lake thaws its going to live in it!

My 5th order of custom lures in 2023 :wink:

.
'No Man Ever Fishes The Same River Twice, .... For It Is Not The Same River, .... And He Is Not The Same Man' Heraclitus of Ephesus
User avatar
DaveGreenwood
Zander
Zander
Posts: 5660
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: On Top

Re: Lure variability

Post by DaveGreenwood »

Mike J wrote: Thu Jan 18 2024 11:40 -
old_school wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:47 -
Mike J wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:00 -
old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Ive fished with a few lures and gave my first DG lure a swim the other day. Not my first custom lure by any means but my first from Dave. You all know how it goes, buy one and give it a good trial, if it looks decent and catches buy more, if something is not quite right store it.
Anyways, hand in heart I can say its the very best slow sinker Ive ever fished, its sink rate is apx 1"/second, yes, seriously slow and-and it sinks level with just a tiny wobble.
Id like to say I caught with it but as of yet I don't even know if there is a pike in the place.

.
Hey Mike, I’ve got a few of Dave’s and the big dippers are superb, can get them deeper than burts and they are more stable, harder wearing too, give one a go if you haven’t all ready, I’ve had several double on the BDs and always one in my box 😎

[font=]I haven't a clue what mine is called[/font], just saw a pic and thought thats what I want, chatted to Dave and he sent me a pic when he'd finished it. Not my first from a PP lure maker (the other was hopeless) so it was a bit of a risk but Dave's mileage gave me the confidence. When the lake thaws its going to live in it!

My 5th order of custom lures in 2023 :wink:

.
It's a Fatjerk Mike.
IMG_20240101_194906_835.jpg
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
User avatar
Mike J
Ferox Trout
Ferox Trout
Posts: 11094
Joined: Wed Nov 09 2016 09:26
Location: Wessex

Re: Lure variability

Post by Mike J »

DaveGreenwood wrote: Thu Jan 18 2024 14:20 -
Mike J wrote: Thu Jan 18 2024 11:40 -
old_school wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:47 -
Mike J wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:00 -
old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Ive fished with a few lures and gave my first DG lure a swim the other day. Not my first custom lure by any means but my first from Dave. You all know how it goes, buy one and give it a good trial, if it looks decent and catches buy more, if something is not quite right store it.
Anyways, hand in heart I can say its the very best slow sinker Ive ever fished, its sink rate is apx 1"/second, yes, seriously slow and-and it sinks level with just a tiny wobble.
Id like to say I caught with it but as of yet I don't even know if there is a pike in the place.

.
Hey Mike, I’ve got a few of Dave’s and the big dippers are superb, can get them deeper than burts and they are more stable, harder wearing too, give one a go if you haven’t all ready, I’ve had several double on the BDs and always one in my box 😎

[font=]I haven't a clue what mine is called[/font], just saw a pic and thought thats what I want, chatted to Dave and he sent me a pic when he'd finished it. Not my first from a PP lure maker (the other was hopeless) so it was a bit of a risk but Dave's mileage gave me the confidence. When the lake thaws its going to live in it!

My 5th order of custom lures in 2023 :wink:

.
It's a Fatjerk Mike.IMG_20240101_194906_835.jpg

Thanks Dave but Im hopeless at remembering lure names, easier to ask for more of the same and let you do the rest :grin:

If the river drops enough I will swim it in there that'll be a test as its chocka with snappers :laughs:


.
'No Man Ever Fishes The Same River Twice, .... For It Is Not The Same River, .... And He Is Not The Same Man' Heraclitus of Ephesus
User avatar
DaveGreenwood
Zander
Zander
Posts: 5660
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: On Top

Re: Lure variability

Post by DaveGreenwood »

Mike J wrote: Fri Jan 19 2024 11:17 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Thu Jan 18 2024 14:20 -
Mike J wrote: Thu Jan 18 2024 11:40 -
old_school wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:47 -
Mike J wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:00 -
old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Ive fished with a few lures and gave my first DG lure a swim the other day. Not my first custom lure by any means but my first from Dave. You all know how it goes, buy one and give it a good trial, if it looks decent and catches buy more, if something is not quite right store it.
Anyways, hand in heart I can say its the very best slow sinker Ive ever fished, its sink rate is apx 1"/second, yes, seriously slow and-and it sinks level with just a tiny wobble.
Id like to say I caught with it but as of yet I don't even know if there is a pike in the place.

.
Hey Mike, I’ve got a few of Dave’s and the big dippers are superb, can get them deeper than burts and they are more stable, harder wearing too, give one a go if you haven’t all ready, I’ve had several double on the BDs and always one in my box 😎

[font=]I haven't a clue what mine is called[/font], just saw a pic and thought thats what I want, chatted to Dave and he sent me a pic when he'd finished it. Not my first from a PP lure maker (the other was hopeless) so it was a bit of a risk but Dave's mileage gave me the confidence. When the lake thaws its going to live in it!

My 5th order of custom lures in 2023 :wink:

.
It's a Fatjerk Mike.IMG_20240101_194906_835.jpg

Thanks Dave but Im hopeless at remembering lure names, easier to ask for more of the same and let you do the rest :grin:

If the river drops enough I will swim it in there that'll be a test as its chocka with snappers :laughs:


.
Add a bit of weight to the nose for a river Mike or will get carried away in the flow, you wont need a lot though :thumbs:
User avatar
Mike J
Ferox Trout
Ferox Trout
Posts: 11094
Joined: Wed Nov 09 2016 09:26
Location: Wessex

Re: Lure variability

Post by Mike J »

DaveGreenwood wrote: Fri Jan 19 2024 11:37 -
Mike J wrote: Fri Jan 19 2024 11:17 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Thu Jan 18 2024 14:20 -
Mike J wrote: Thu Jan 18 2024 11:40 -
old_school wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:47 -
Mike J wrote: Wed Jan 17 2024 10:00 -
old_school wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 16:33 -
DaveGreenwood wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 14:03 -
Mike J wrote: Tue Jan 16 2024 12:08 -
Oldskoolfool wrote: Sat Jan 13 2024 10:11 -
Due to the floods & storms spent a lot of time sorting the lure collection

On reflection am I thr only one who sees performance variability in different lures of the same brand? I could expect it with wooden lures but on some of the mass produced lures different lures of thr same model perform differently.


Ilthis to me is most obvious in jerks like Burts and some of the old Fox lures - one has s good responsive action whereas another is nothing close almost duff.

Also during a lures commercial life I see changes as well so older first to market models are great whereas later model less so

What do you do try to fix em or pass them on ?

Thoughts
Mass produced lures usually begin life being made where the original design was conceived, then when they become popular production is moved to where they can be produced cheaper and in greater numbers.
Forgetting lures for a moment and look at the iconic VW Golf, possibly the finest small saloon ever built, now its a mishmash of parts badly assembled in Mexico. Assembly is so bad they are even forgetting something as basic as the rubber plugs in the floor panels. Coincidently Burts are also made in Mexico.
Castiacs are another, the first were tough, well balanced and caught, then China became involved and we know the rest.
ABU multipliers, brilliantly engineered and made in Sweden, now nobody with any sense wants them unless they are those ABU produce specifically for the Japanese market.


Buy as soon as a lure hits the market and hope it works or have them made by specialists who are pike anglers is my tip :thumbs:

.
Pretty sure VW stopped Golf production in Mexico 3 or 4 years ago Mike, agree about Burts though they are thrown together now it’s a lottery what comes out the packet. :laughs:
It’s about time some enterprising lure maker started 3D printing the 2 half’s of burts so they could be weighted to suit the individual before being joined together. Some mini and midi sized burts could be easy with some resizing of the code I imagine. Dave, have you thought about a 3D printer at all…
Ive fished with a few lures and gave my first DG lure a swim the other day. Not my first custom lure by any means but my first from Dave. You all know how it goes, buy one and give it a good trial, if it looks decent and catches buy more, if something is not quite right store it.
Anyways, hand in heart I can say its the very best slow sinker Ive ever fished, its sink rate is apx 1"/second, yes, seriously slow and-and it sinks level with just a tiny wobble.
Id like to say I caught with it but as of yet I don't even know if there is a pike in the place.

.
Hey Mike, I’ve got a few of Dave’s and the big dippers are superb, can get them deeper than burts and they are more stable, harder wearing too, give one a go if you haven’t all ready, I’ve had several double on the BDs and always one in my box 😎

[font=]I haven't a clue what mine is called[/font], just saw a pic and thought thats what I want, chatted to Dave and he sent me a pic when he'd finished it. Not my first from a PP lure maker (the other was hopeless) so it was a bit of a risk but Dave's mileage gave me the confidence. When the lake thaws its going to live in it!

My 5th order of custom lures in 2023 :wink:

.
It's a Fatjerk Mike.IMG_20240101_194906_835.jpg

Thanks Dave but Im hopeless at remembering lure names, easier to ask for more of the same and let you do the rest :grin:

If the river drops enough I will swim it in there that'll be a test as its chocka with snappers :laughs:


.
Add a bit of weight to the nose for a river Mike or will get carried away in the flow, you wont need a lot though :thumbs:
:handshake:

.
'No Man Ever Fishes The Same River Twice, .... For It Is Not The Same River, .... And He Is Not The Same Man' Heraclitus of Ephesus
Post Reply