Page 1 of 1

Squid?

Posted: Tue Nov 22 2022 11:50
by LlyrEdwards
Hello all,

As I also sea fish I have a considerable amount of squid in the freezer at all times.

Has anyone tried it for pike with any success ?


Thanks,

Tom

Re: Squid?

Posted: Tue Nov 22 2022 12:26
by Steve Dennington
Only once and didn't catch.

Re: Squid?

Posted: Tue Nov 22 2022 22:28
by stubbojo
my old fishing pal .. roy martin what a character he was ,no longer with us ......used to swear by squid seen him catch a 15lb pike on one ....

r.i.p ....

Re: Squid?

Posted: Wed Nov 23 2022 02:03
by Poots
I recall an article by Trevor Housby extolling the virtues. I've always liked it for sea fishing and it is a reputable cat bait.
Cyprinus likes it in various extracts too but it's not something I would automatically choose over macks or sardines..

Re: Squid?

Posted: Wed Nov 23 2022 09:34
by davelumb
Eels love a bit of squid.

Re: Squid?

Posted: Thu Nov 24 2022 10:58
by LlyrEdwards
davelumb wrote: ↑Wed Nov 23 2022 09:34 -
Eels love a bit of squid.
Yep and it stays on the hook pretty damn well too. Biggest issue I had was the carp kept taking it! Although I did also catch a fair few carp on roach lives and deads πŸ˜‚

Re: Squid?

Posted: Thu Nov 24 2022 11:00
by davelumb
LlyrEdwards wrote: ↑Thu Nov 24 2022 10:58 -
davelumb wrote: ↑Wed Nov 23 2022 09:34 -
Eels love a bit of squid.
Yep and it stays on the hook pretty damn well too. Biggest issue I had was the carp kept taking it! Although I did also catch a fair few carp on roach lives and deads πŸ˜‚
Aye, carp do like it. But carp eat anything!

Re: Squid?

Posted: Sat Nov 26 2022 21:46
by horseshoe3
Tried squid for pike, never had eny

Re: Squid?

Posted: Sun Nov 27 2022 21:49
by LlyrEdwards
horseshoe3 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 26 2022 21:46 -
Tried squid for pike, never had eny
Sounds like I’d be better off keeping it for the cod and bass

Re: Squid?

Posted: Thu Dec 01 2022 22:45
by Mark Phillips
LlyrEdwards wrote: ↑Tue Nov 22 2022 11:50 -
Hello all,

As I also sea fish I have a considerable amount of squid in the freezer at all times.

Has anyone tried it for pike with any success ?


Thanks,

Tom
Caught plenty of catfish with it. No joy with pike, but only tried it a couple of times as an experiment. I see no reason it won't work, given I've seen pike caught on static boilies! But, with other baits being proven catchers, why would you use it :scratch:

Re: Squid?

Posted: Thu Dec 01 2022 22:59
by stubbojo
Mark Phillips wrote: ↑Thu Dec 01 2022 22:45 -
LlyrEdwards wrote: ↑Tue Nov 22 2022 11:50 -
Hello all,

As I also sea fish I have a considerable amount of squid in the freezer at all times.

Has anyone tried it for pike with any success ?


Thanks,

Tom
Caught plenty of catfish with it. No joy with pike, but only tried it a couple of times as an experiment. I see no reason it won't work, given I've seen pike caught on static boilies! But, with other baits being proven catchers, why would you use it :scratch:
correct mark , but my mate spotted some mixed in with my baits , and said ... i am trying that ......then he had one :laughs: :laughs:

Re: Squid?

Posted: Fri Dec 02 2022 09:03
by LlyrEdwards
Mark Phillips wrote: ↑Thu Dec 01 2022 22:45 -
LlyrEdwards wrote: ↑Tue Nov 22 2022 11:50 -
Hello all,

As I also sea fish I have a considerable amount of squid in the freezer at all times.

Has anyone tried it for pike with any success ?


Thanks,

Tom
Caught plenty of catfish with it. No joy with pike, but only tried it a couple of times as an experiment. I see no reason it won't work, given I've seen pike caught on static boilies! But, with other baits being proven catchers, why would you use it :scratch:
Because Im a bit odd. Haha no it’s just because I’ve got loads of it to hand.

Re: Squid?

Posted: Sat Dec 03 2022 00:03
by Mark Phillips
LlyrEdwards wrote: ↑Fri Dec 02 2022 09:03 -
Mark Phillips wrote: ↑Thu Dec 01 2022 22:45 -
LlyrEdwards wrote: ↑Tue Nov 22 2022 11:50 -
Hello all,

As I also sea fish I have a considerable amount of squid in the freezer at all times.

Has anyone tried it for pike with any success ?


Thanks,

Tom
Caught plenty of catfish with it. No joy with pike, but only tried it a couple of times as an experiment. I see no reason it won't work, given I've seen pike caught on static boilies! But, with other baits being proven catchers, why would you use it :scratch:
Because Im a bit odd. Haha no it’s just because I’ve got loads of it to hand.
Fair point :thumbs: Just thinking it through, when I've used it for cats, on waters where pike are also present, not once have I had a pike. You should get the topic moved to the relevant forum, as a few more catfish guys might have had different experiences with it :shrug:

Re: Squid?

Posted: Thu Jul 13 2023 15:27
by horseshoe3
Tried squid 20 odd years ago on 2 or 3 pike waters, no pike and I thought it would work.

Re: Squid?

Posted: Thu Jul 13 2023 15:42
by delboy
Back in the day I used calamary squid and did catch on it, I remembered this and about 3 years ago I tried some on my local, I just dropped it in the edge ,in 6ft of clear water and saw a small pike come up and nose it about 3 times and then he took it

Re: Squid?

Posted: Thu Jul 13 2023 15:45
by delboy
Just remembered, also used squid/octopus chunks in the summer back home on the pits and had tench on them

Re: Squid?

Posted: Fri Jul 14 2023 06:19
by Noblest savage
A strip of squid on a jig hook and fished like a lure has worked for me, also mackerel strip in the same fashion.

Cheers
Ben